Evidence Hub

1716 Why do emergency department clinicians miss acute aortic syndrome? A case series and descriptive analysis

R. McLatchie, Sarah J. Wilson, M. Reed, Francoise Ticehurst, Kathryn Easterford, Salma Alawiye, Alicia Cowan, Aakash N. Gupta

Emergency Medicine Journal, 2022

4,000 participants · 3 citations

Abstract

Aims, Objectives and Background Acute aortic syndrome (AAS) is a rare, life-threatening emergency affecting approximately 4000 people per year in the UK, has an ED misdiagnosis rate as high as 38% and around one quarter of cases are not diagnosed until 24 hours after presenting to the ED. It presents in many atypical ways, posing a significant diagnostic conundrum for the emergency department (ED) clinician and risk of litigation. We sought to understand the reasons why AAS was missed in ED by conducting a case series review of patients with misidentified AAS presenting to three UK EDs over a 10-year period. Method and Design We identified missed diagnoses of AAS using searches of ED morbidity and mortality records, post-mortem reports, complaints, Electronic Patient Records (EPRs) and Radiology records from three UK EDs. Results and Conclusion Between 1.1.2011–31.12.2020, 43 cases were identified across three EDs (1.4 cases/yr/dept). The most common diagnosis was Type A aortic dissection (22; 51%). The most common incorrect presumed diagnoses made were acute coronary syndrome (ACS, 12; 28%), pulmonary embolism (PE, 5; 12%) and ‘non-specific chest pain’ (5; 12%). In 31 of the 43 cases (72%) there was no evidence from the notes of consideration of AAS in the differential diagnosis. In 10 of the 43 cases (23%), AAS was clearly considered, but the clinician appears to have been falsely reassured by clinical findings, normal chest x-ray, or atypical or resolved symptoms. Only…

Read the paper

Related studies

Go deeper in Evidence Hub

Evidence Hub adds a study data sheet (design, sample size, evidence level, key numbers), an AI summary and a chat grounded in the paper's text.

Open this study Sign up free