Why does rate of bone density loss not predict fracture risk?
Abstract
CONTEXT: Intuitively, rapid bone mineral density (BMD) loss should predict fracture risk independently of current BMD, but studies have not confirmed this. We hypothesized that measurement error when characterizing rates of BMD loss might explain this paradox.
OBJECTIVE: To examine the importance of measurement error in predicting BMD loss.
DESIGN AND SETTING: Retrospective registry study using BMD results for Manitoba, Canada.
PATIENTS: Untreated women age 50 years and older with three femoral neck BMD tests.
MAIN OUTCOME MEASURES: Correlation in annualized rates of BMD change for interval 1 (first to second scan) versus interval 2 (second to third scan) with confirmatory model-based simulations that varied measurement error and testing intervals.
RESULTS: Five hundred forty two women with a mean age of 62 years had BMD measurements separated by a mean of 3.5 years for interval 1 and 3.4 years for interval 2. Mean femoral neck BMD loss was stable (-0.5% per year for interval 1, -0.6% per year for interval 2) with a weak negative correlation between intervals (r = -0.11, P = .01). There were no significant correlations for BMD change at the total hip (r = 0.01, P = .74) or total spine (r = -0.01, P = .77). Simulations showed low explained variation for BMD change between intervals 1 and 2 (<20%). To explain 50% of the variation of BMD change between intervals 1 and 2 required a BMD measurement error ≤ 0.008 g/cm(2) or a BMD testing interval ≥ 5 years.
CONCLUSIONS: The low…
How strong is the evidence?
Evidence Hub reads this as a cohort study, done in people. Its evidence level is 3 of 5 (Moderate · trial / cohort / secondary analysis). Trials without a large randomized design, cohorts and secondary analyses give moderate evidence.
Read the paper
Related studies
- Development of a crushable foam model for human trabecular bone
- Data-driven motion compensation in HR-pQCT.
- Modeling of structure, quality, and function in the orthodontic patient
- Exploring the mechanism of Heidihuang Pill in the treatment of osteoporosis based on network pharmacology, molecular docking, and experimental validation
- Effect of fabric on the accuracy of computed tomography-based finite element analyses of the vertebra
- Use of interventions involving virtual reality tasks during the climacteric: a systematic review
Go deeper in Evidence Hub
Evidence Hub adds a study data sheet (design, sample size, evidence level, key numbers), an AI summary and a chat grounded in the paper's text.